f90x wrote:Once a HIFI anorak always a HIFI anorak
Ain't that the truth.
I remember very well a hifi show that was run by the then University Audio shop in Cambridge - this was 1979 and I was a spotty 14 yr old and had just got my first 'proper' hifi system.
At the show, the plan was to put the LP12 up against a JBE Slate direct drive turntable. It was a fairly high end system which was built up around it, and it did sound very good indeed. A rumour had gone around (later confirmed) that on the thurs evening, during the setting up of the show, the turntables were put through their paces with the JBE showing the Linn up as a poor 2nd place. The JBE never turned another revolution all weekend, being claimed as 'faulty' despite punters' repeated requests to have it playing. When asked to get the JBE playing, the show organisers became very defensive.
Whilst there is so much controversy surrounding the Ariston vs Linn debate the bottom line is that both turntables were hard to
not be seen as copies - well engineered ones admittedly - of the TD150. Even down to the springs in the suspension system which were in identical places and following the exact same principles of acoustic isolation (a Linn subchassis will drop straight in to a TD150's for example).
A couple of years ago I was invited along to an unofficial turntable comparison test by the owner of Nene Valley Audio. Turntables on test were...
1. Technics SP10 Mk3/SME 312 (12" Series V)
2. Garrard 401/heavily modded Rega RB300
3. Pioneer PL-71
4. Linn LP12/Ekos SE
Out of these, my favourite was the Garrard by a nose over the Pioneer which came second. Third was the SP10 and last was the LP12.
Having owned a couple of good direct drive turntables, and a Garrard 401, I find it extremely hard to listen to belt drive now - it always sounds wayward, lacking focus. The sheer drive, punch and stability of a DD's/ID's sound is a major eye-opener - it's nearer to listening to master tape.
One more bit of irony - Ivor T of Linn said recently that if he had the chance to start all over again with the LP12, he would have made it a direct drive. Very cruel when you consider he was one of the main reasons why direct drive never got the recognition it deserved in the 70's/80's. Easy to say now that it poses no threat any more.